F&M All-Americans by Year
| Name | Event | Year |
| Gregg Weir | 100 Backstroke | 1971 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 100 Backstroke | 1979 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 200 Freestyle | 1980 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 500 Freestyle | 1980 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 100 Backstroke | 1980 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 50 Backstroke | 1980 |
| Kittie Callaghan | 100 Backstroke | 1980 |
| Kittie Callaghan | 200 Backstroke | 1980 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 200 Freestyle | 1981 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 500 Freestyle | 1981 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 100 Backstroke | 1981 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 200 Backstroke | 1981 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 50 Backstroke | 1981 |
| Kathryn Prinz, Sheila Wren, Tanya Blakeman, Barbara Schumacher, Carolyn J. Warter | 400 Medley Relay | 1981 |
| Sheila Wren | 100 Breaststroke | 1981 |
| Sheila Wren | 200 Breaststroke | 1981 |
| Sheila Wren | 50 Breaststroke | 1981 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 200 Freestyle | 1982 |
| Allen G. Barry III | 500 Freestyle | 1982 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 100 Backstroke | 1982 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 200 Backstroke | 1982 |
| Kathryn Prinz | 50 Backstroke | 1982 |
| Tanya Blakeman | 1650 Freestyle | 1982 |
| Tanya Blakeman | 200 Freestyle | 1982 |
| Tanya Blakeman | 500 Freestyle | 1982 |
| Penny Blakeman | 100 Backstroke | 1983 |
| Penny Blakeman | 100 Butterfly | 1983 |
| Penny Blakeman | 50 Backstroke | 1983 |
| Wendy Somers | 50 Backstroke | 1983 |
| Wendy Somers | 100 Backstroke | 1985 |
| Wendy Somers | 50 Freestyle | 1985 |
| Penny Blakeman | 100 Backstroke | 1986 |
| Megan Devine | 100 Butterfly | 1989 |
| Megan Devine | 200 Butterfly | 1989 |
| Darragh Donnelly, Larissa Swales, Jennifer Gareis, Megan Devine, | 200 Freestyle Relay | 1990 |
| Jennifer Gareis | 100 Butterfly | 1990 |
| Jennifer Gareis, Darragh Donnelly, Megan Devine, Larissa Swales | 200 Medley Relay | 1990 |
| Jennifer Gareis, Darragh Donnelly, Megan Devine, Larissa Swales | 400 Medley Relay | 1990 |
| Megan Devine | 200 Butterfly | 1990 |
| Megan Devine | 400 IM | 1990 |
| Megan Devine | 500 Freestyle | 1990 |
| Deborah Christman | 200 Butterfly | 1991 |
| Deborah Christman | 400 IM | 1991 |
| Deborah Christman | 500 Freestyle | 1991 |
| Jennifer Gareis | 100 Butterfly | 1991 |
| Jeni Wheeler | 100 Backstroke | 1992 |
| Jeni Wheeler | 200 Backstroke | 1992 |
| Jeni Wheeler | 200 Butterfly | 1992 |
| Jodi Woods | 200 Backstroke | 1992 |
| Jodi Woods | 100 Backstroke | 1993 |
| Jodi Woods | 200 Breaststroke | 1993 |
| Jodi Woods | 200 IM | 1993 |
| Jodi Woods | 200 Breaststroke | 1994 |
| Jodi Woods | 200 IM | 1994 |
| Jodi Woods | 400 IM | 1994 |
| Carmen Trombini | 100 Breaststroke | 1995 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 Breaststroke | 1995 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 IM | 1995 |
| Carmen Trombini | 100 Breaststroke | 1996 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 Breaststroke | 1996 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 IM | 1996 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 IM | 1997 |
| Carmen Trombini | 400 IM | 1997 |
| Carmen Trombini | 200 IM | 1998 |
| Stephen Michaels | 200 Butterfly | 1998 |
| Stephen Miller | 1650 Freestyle | 1998 |
| Stephen Miller | 400 IM | 1998 |
| Stephen Michaels | 200 Butterfly | 1999 |
| Stephen Miller | 1650 Freestyle | 1999 |
| Stephen Miller | 400 IM | 1999 |
| Stephen Michaels | 200 Butterfly | 2000 |
| Krystle Satrum | 100 Backstroke | 2002 |
| Krystle Satrum | 200 Backstroke | 2002 |
| Matthew Muehe | 50 Freestyle | 2002 |
| Krystle Satrum | 100 Backstroke | 2003 |
| Krystle Satrum | 200 Backstroke | 2003 |
| Jenna Walters | 200 Freestyle | 2004 |
| Jenna Walters | 500 Freestyle | 2004 |
| Krystle Satrum | 100 Backstroke | 2004 |
| Krystle Satrum | 200 Backstroke | 2004 |
| Derek Nowak | 1650 Freestyle | 2005 |
| Derek Nowak | 500 Freestyle | 2005 |
| Elizabeth Kraljic | 200 Breaststroke | 2005 |
| Jenna Walters | 200 Freestyle | 2005 |
| Jenna Walters | 500 Freestyle | 2005 |
| Kelly Landman | 400 IM | 2005 |
| Brittany McCabe | 100 Backstroke | 2006 |
| Brittany McCabe | 100 Butterfly | 2006 |
| Derek Nowak | 1650 Freestyle | 2006 |
| Jenna Walters | 100 Freestyle | 2006 |
| Jenna Walters | 200 Freestyle | 2006 |
| Jenna Walters | 500 Freestyle | 2006 |
| John Czaplicki | 50 Freestyle | 2006 |
| Kelly Landman | 200 Butterfly | 2006 |
| Brittany McCabe | 100 Backstroke | 2007 |
| Jenna Walters | 200 Freestyle | 2007 |
| Jenna Walters | 500 Freestyle | 2007 |
| Kelly Landman | 200 Butterfly | 2007 |
| Kelly Landman | 400 IM | 2007 |
| Brittany McCabe | 100 Backstroke | 2008 |
| Tom Grabiak | 200 Breaststroke | 2008 |
| Brittany McCabe | 200 Backstroke | 2009 |
| Tom Grabiak | 200 IM | 2009 |
| Tom Grabiak | 100 Breaststroke | 2009 |
| Tom Grabiak | 200 Breaststroke | 2009 |
