F&M Men's Basketball All-Conference Selections
| Name | Pos | Team (Year) |
| Anderson, Donnie | F | 1st (1982), HM (1981) |
| Boylan, Bob | 1st (1976, 1975) | |
| Cordes, Mike | C | 1st (1975) |
| Detz, Charlie | F | 1st (1995) |
| Fabian, Josh | F | HM (1997) |
| Fain, Larry | G | HM (2001) |
| Finch, Chris | G | 1st (1992) |
| Ganot, Asaf | G | 1st (2003) |
| Henry, Jeremiah | G | 1st (1996), 2nd (1995) |
| Hoeker, Phil | C | 2nd (1989) |
| Janneta, Dave | G | 1st (1995) |
| Juskin, Steve | F | 1st (2004, 2003) |
| Kraft, Alex | F | 1st (2001, 2000) 2nd (1999) |
| Lasky, Will | G | 1st (1992) |
| Leddy, Matt | G | 1st (1999), HM (1998) |
| Lynch, Dan | F | HM (2005) |
| Maiatico, Jerome | G | 1st (1998),2nd (2000) |
| Manaskie, Bob | G | 1st (1979) |
| Markey, Brad | G | 1st (1989, 1988) |
| Marsh, Donnie | G | 1st (1979, 1977, 1976), 2nd (1975) |
| McNally, James | F | 1st (2009) |
| Mehaffey, Mike | F | 1st (1996, 1995) |
| Menet, Brian | 1st (1988) | |
| Milligan, Georgio | G | 1st (2009) |
| Plakans, Ed | F | 1st (1993) |
| Ritacco, Mike | G | 2nd (2000) |
| Russell, Ned | F | 1st (1968) |
| Sanborn, Darren | F | 2nd (1998, 1996) |
| Scott, Terry | F | 1st (1988, 1987, 1986) |
| Searles, Duran | G | 1st (2004), 2nd (2003) |
| Smith, Brandon | G | 1st (2007, 2006) |
| Snodgrass, Doug | G | 1st (1974) |
| Taylor, Allen | G | 1st (1982) |
| Thomas, Cas | G | 2nd (2001) |
| Valentine, Ron | 1st (1973) | |
| Westley, Dennis | F | 1st (1981, 1980, 1979) |
| Worley, Mark | F | 1st (1977) |
| Wright, Jackiem | G | 2nd (2005, 2004, 2003) |
